Abstract

Research Article

Regulatory requirements and assessment of scientific research by a psychiatrist when considering the issue of assigning a qualifying doctor`s category

Shapovalov KA*, Shapovalova PK and Shapovalova LA

Published: 20 April, 2021 | Volume 5 - Issue 1 | Pages: 025-032

Introduction: In accordance with the requirements for the preparation of a report, a physician must provide information on scientific research in the following sections to obtain a qualification category of a specialist: 6. Scientific and practical work (participation in scientific and practical conferences, medical scientific societies, presentations, publications); 11.2. List of publications of the attested in scientific journals and collections, abstracts and 11.3. List of speeches at international, all-Russian and republican conferences.

Material and methods: The analysis of 5 qualification works of a psychiatrist (1997, 2002, 2008, 2013 and 2018) for the scientific component as part of the mandatory requirements for the processing of documents when they are submitted to the Attestation Commission on the assignment of a qualifying medical category in psychiatry . The depth of the study was 24 years. When working on the material, the following methodical approaches were used: system, complex, dynamic, normative, quantitative and situational. Methods of analysis included: historical, analytical and comparison. For the analysis, methods were used: groupings, absolute values, continuous and selective observations.

Results: The psychiatrist GAUZ “KDC” independently or in co-authorship published 223 scientific and educational-methodical publications (total volume of 182.65 conventional author’s sheets), including 90 scientific (39.81) and 143 educational-methodical (142.84) works, in including one monograph and eight textbooks (two of them with the stamp of the Ministry of Education of the Russian Federation). In the e-library (www.e-library.ru) of the Russian Scientific Citation Index (RINC): publications - 31; citations - 123; Hirsch index - 3, publications in the journals of the VAK - 13. (https://elibrary.ru/author).

Discussion: The scientific work of a practicing outpatient psychiatrist is assessed both quantitatively and qualitatively, the integral indicator of the psychiatrist’s own participation in each publication of 0.78 conventional printed sheets can be considered as a serious personal contribution to scientific research.

In the regulatory framework of indicators and requirements for registration of the report there is no synchronization in the daily work of a practical doctor, his job duties with the statements of the report. When concluding an employment contract with the employer, there is no mention in it that the doctor should engage in scientific work, and it is an integral part of his functional duties and qualification requirements. The scientific work does not mention the “Unified qualification directory of positions of managers, specialists and employees, the section “Qualification characteristics of the positions of employees in the field of health care” for a psychiatrist.

Conclusion: The attitude to the Administrative Regulations on the provision of a public service for assigning a qualification category to specialists engaged in medical and pharmaceutical activities should be reviewed in terms of synchronization with the duties of a doctor. The Regulation on the compulsory conduct of scientific research should be introduced, substantiated and provided by the employer or be excluded from the administrative regulations as an independent section and be exclusively recommendatory in nature.

Publications of physicians in scientific journals and collections, theses of reports should motivate their interest, and within the limits of the possibilities of the medical institution to have reasonable financial support, fixed in the employment contract.

An example of a practical doctor who speaks at international, all-Russian or republican congresses, congresses and conferences is an important indicator of his professional growth, an incentive for the disclosure and development of the potential of the medical institution team and the result of proper administrative and organizational-methodological guidance.

The scientific work and publications of a psychiatrist’s practical doctor should be a weighty additional argument in favor of a positive decision on awarding the qualification category he has declared.

Read Full Article HTML DOI: 10.29328/journal.apmh.1001032 Cite this Article Read Full Article PDF

Keywords:

Scientific work; Qualification category; Psychiatrist

References

  1. Order of the Ministry of Health No. 240n dated 04/23/2013 “On the Procedure and Dates of Passing Certification by Medical and Pharmaceutical Workers to Receive a Qualification Category”. (Registered in the Ministry of Justice of the Russian Federation on July 5, 2013).
  2. Order of the Ministry of Health and Social Development of the Russian Federation of July 23, 2010 N 541н "On approval of the Unified Qualification Guide for the positions of managers, specialists and employees, section" Qualification Characteristics of the Positions of Workers in the Field of Health Care "(Registered in the Ministry of Justice of the Russian Federation on August 25, 2010 N 18247).
  3. Appendix No. 3 to the Administrative Regulation for the provision of public services for the assignment of a qualification category to specialists engaged in medical and pharmaceutical activities in the territory of the Komi Republic, in the manner established by the authorized federal executive body.
  4. Professor SN. Mosolov: Naukometricheskie pokazateli – vazhnye kriterii ocenki rezul'tatov nauchnoj deyatel'nosti. Interv'yu. Rossijskij psihiatricheskij zhurnal 2018;2:88-91.
  5. Kazakov RA. Optimizaciya nauchnoj deyatel'nosti medicinskoj organizacii na osnove principov menedzhmenta kachestva. Avtoreferat na soiskanie uchyonoj stepeni kandidata medicinskih nauk. Novosibirsk. 2014. Pubmed: https://www.dissercat.com/content/optimizatsiya-nauchnoi-deyatelnosti-meditsinskoi-organizatsii-na-osnove-printsipov-menedzhme
  6. Shapovalova LA. Organization of work of the specialized psychiatric bureau of medical and social expertise in 1994-1996 Syktyvkar, 1997.
  7. Shapovalova LA. Certification materials of a psychotherapist of the Republican Center for Socio-psychological, medical rehabilitation of former military personnel and persons with disabilities. Syktyvkar, 2002.
  8. Shapovalova LA. On the Work of the Psychiatrist of Advisory Department of State Agency of Health “Advisory and Diagnostic Centre of the Republic of Komi" in 2005-2007. Syktyvkar, 2007.
  9. Shapovalova LA. Analysis of the Work of the Psychiatrist of Avisory Departmet of the State Autonomous Health Agency of the Republic of Komi "Consultive and Diagnostic Centre of the Republic of Komi" in 2010-2012. Syktyvkar, 2012.
  10. Shapovalova LA. Analysis of the Work of the Psychiatrist of Avisory Departmet of the State Autonomous Health Agency of the Republic of Komi "Consultive and Diagnostic Centre of the Republic of Komi" in 2015-2017. Syktyvkar, 2018.
  11. Shapovalov KA, Shapovalova LA. Bases of didactics of an educational theme «Training of the population to first-aid treatment at thermal defeats, electric, thermal and beam burns, freezing injuries in the conditions of emergency situations». Bezopasnost Zhiznedejatelnosti 2015; 4: 67-72.
  12. Niculina TI, Shapovalov KA, Shapovalova LA. Additional professional training program of teachers of educational institutions "Providing first emergency aid to victims". Syktyvkar, Komi Republican Institute for Educational Development. 2016.
  13. Shapovalov KA, Shapovalova LA. Basics of Didactics of Theme "Closed Damages" of Training Module "The First (Pre-Medical Emergency) Assistance for Traumas Suffered During Accidents, Catastrophes and Natural Disasters" of Subject "Life Safety" for Humanitarian and Technical Universities. Bezopasnost Zhiznedejatelnosti. 2016; 2: 56-64.
  14. Shapovalov KA, Shapovalova LA. Basics of Didactics of Theme "Bleeding" of Training Module "The First (Pre-Medical Emergency) Assistance for Traumas Suffered During Accidents, Catastrophes and Natural Disasters" of Subject "Life Safety" for Humanitarian and Technical Universities. Bezopasnost Zhiznedejatelnosti. 2016; 4: 51-61.
  15. Shapovalov KA, Shapovalova LA. Bases of Didactics of Theme "Fractures" of Educational Module "The First (Pre-Medical Emergency) Assistance for Injuries Suffered During Accidents, Catastrophes and Natural Disasters" of Subject "Safety" for Humanitarian and Technical Universities. Bezopasnost Zhiznedejatelnosti. 2016; 7: 54-61.
  16. Shapovalov KA, Shapovalova LA. Additional Professonal Training Program of Distance Learning Course "First Aid for Injuries and Accidents". Syktyvkar, Komi Republican Institute for Educational Development, 2017.
  17. Shapovalov KA, Shapovalova LA. Bases of Didactics of Theme "Damage to the Head, Neck and Spinal Column" of Educational Module "The First (Pre-Medical Emergency) Assistance for Traumas Suffered During Accidents, Catastrophes and Natural Disasters" of Subject "Life Safety" for Humanitarian and Technical Universities. Bezopasnost Zhiznedejatelnosti. 2017; 4: 54-64.
  18. Shapovalov KA, Shapovalova LA, Yastrebtseva T, Gusarova S, Bairova E. Disabled children. Standards of primary, general disability, major violations in health status and leading disability of disabled children in city children's polyclinic of regional center of subarctic territory. Pediatrics. Eastern Europe. 2017; 5: 254-269.
  19. Shapovalova LA, Shapovalov КА. Features of work of psychiatrist of Regional consultative diagnostic center of Subarctic Territory. Independent Psychiatric J. 2016; 3: 68-74.
  20. Shapovalov КА, Shapovalova LА. Methodological approaches to teaching academic theme "Wounds" of subject "First aid for injuries suffered during accidents, catasthrophes and natural disasters" for humanitarian and technical universities. 19th World Congress for Disaster and Emergency Medicine. 2015; 380.
  21. Shapovalov КА, Shapovalova LА. The Author's Program of Subject "First Aid for Traumas in Accidents and Natural Disasters" for Non-medical Faculties of Humanities and Technical Universities. 19th World Congress for Disaster and Emergency Medicine, 21-24 April 2015, Cape Town, South Africa. Abstracts 634.
  22. Shapovalov КА, Shapovalova LА. Didactic of Training Topic "Fetal Alcohol Syndrome". 3d ASIAN CLINICAL CONGRESS (ACC3). Tokio, Japan. 2015.
  23. Shapovalov КA, Shapovalova LA. Demographic Characteristics of the Cohort of Patients, Receiving Outpatient Psychiatric Help in Regional Medical Consultative and Diagnostic Center of Sub-Arctic Territory. European Psychiatry. 2017; 41: 578.
  24. Shapovalov КA, Shapovalova LA. Structure of Psychic Sphere Pathology of Patients of the Regional Medical Consultative and Diagnostic Center of Sub-Arctic Territory. European Psychiatry. 2017; 41: 578-579.
  25. Shapovalov КА, Shapovalova LА. First Aid for Wounds to Victims of Accidents, Catastrophes and Natural Disasters. Geneva: World Health Organization. 2017; 1-20.
  26. Shapovalov КА, Shapovalova LА. First Aid for Head, Neck and Spine Injuries to Victims of Accidents, Catastrophes and Natural Disasters. Geneva: World Health Organization. 2017; 1-47.
  27. Shapovalov КА, Shapovalova LА. Standard of primary disability for city children’s clinic of regional centre of subarctic territory. Archives of Disease in Childhood. 2017; 102: A114.
  28. Shapovalov КА, Shapovalova LА. Control over execution of individual program of rehabilitation and (or) habilitation of children with disabilities. experience of city children’s clinic of regional centre of subarctic territory. Arch Dis Child. 2017; 102: A114-A115.
  29. Shapovalov КА, Shapovalova LА. Methodological approaches to teaching academic theme "Burns" subject "First aid for injuries suffered during accidents" for humanitarian and technical universities. WCICT 2017 WOUND CARE From Innovations to Clinical Trials. Abstracts No. 1012. 2017.
  30. Shapovalov КА, Shapovalova LА. Organization of emergency care at occupational wounds to members of vessel`s crews on ships of the Northern water`s basin. WCICT 2017 WOUND CARE From Innovations to Clinical Trials. Abstracts No. 1014. 20-21. 2017.
  31. Shapovalov КА, Shapovalova LА. Author's Program of Subject «Fundamentals of a Healthy Lifestyle» for Non-Medical Faculties of Humanitarian and Technical Universities. ICSS 2017 International Conference on Social Sciences & Interdisciplinary Studies. Abstracts Ref. No: ICSS-ABS-APR-241. 2017.
  32. Shapovalov КА, Shapovalova LА. The Author's Training Program and Methodical Complex «Basics of a Healthy LifeStyle» for the Prevention of Traumatism of Members of Vessel`s Crew. GPC 2017 2nd International Conference on General Practice & Primary Care. Abstracts Ref. No: GPC-ABS-APR-82. 2017.
  33. Shapovalov KA, Shapovalova LA. Traumatism in alcoholic intoxication as marker of dependence or progressive disease on example of fishermen of the Northern water`s basin. WPA 2018 World Psychiatric Associations Thematic Congress “INNOVATION IN PSYCHIATRY: EFFECTIVE INTERVENTIONS FOR HEALTH & SOCIETY”. 25-28. 2018.
  34. Shapovalov KA, Shapovalova LA. Scientific research as an integral part of the work of a psychiatrist leading an outpatient consultation in the regional diagnostic center of the Subarctic territory. European Psychiatry. 2018; 48: 755-756.
  35. Shapovalova LA, Shapovalov КА. Outpatient Consulting Care of Psychiatrist on Population of SubArctic territory. RC Psych International Congress. 2016.
  36. Shapovalova LA, Shapovalov КА. Questions of the Organization and Results of the Work of Psychiatrist of Advisory Department of the Regional Diagnostic Center of Sub-Arctic Territory with Low Population Density. Geneva: World Health Organization. 2016; 1-25.
  37. Shapovalova LA, Shapovalov КA. Approbation of new drugs and treatment methods into practice of outpatient psychiatrist at regional diagnostic center of subarctic territory. WPA 2018 World Psychiatric Associations Thematic Congress “INNOVATION IN PSYCHIATRY: EFFECTIVE INTERVENTIONS FOR HEALTH & SOCIETY”. Melbourne, Australia. 2018.
  38. Shapovalova LA, Shapovalov КA. Training of psychiatrist of regional diagnostic center of subarctic territory for work in emergency situations of catastrophes and natural disasters. WPA 2018 World Psychiatric Associations Thematic Congress “INNOVATION IN PSYCHIATRY: EFFECTIVE INTERVENTIONS FOR HEALTH & SOCIETY”. Melbourne, Australia. 2018.
  39. Shapovalova LA, Shapovalov КA. Features pathology newly diagnosed by a psychiatrist at the reception of the regional advisory diagnostic center of subarctic territory. European Psychiatry. 2018; 48: 569.
  40. Shapovalova LA, Shapovalov KA. Organizational and methodical work as an integral part of the qualifi cation category of a psychiatrist of the consultative department of the regional diagnostic center of the subarctic territory. Mental Health. 2018; 7: 3-11.
  41. Shapovalova LA, Shapovalov КА. Characteristics of the pathology of the mental sphere of a contingent of patients on an outpatient visit to a psychiatrist of the consultative and diagnostic center of the subarctic territory. Psychiatry, Psychotherapy and Clinical Psychology. 2018; 9: 515-533.
  42. Shapovalova LA, Shapovalov КА. The work of the medical service of civil defense and emergency situations as an integral part of the qualification category of a psychiatrist. Psychiatry (Moscow) (Psihiatriya). 2018; 16: 40–52.
  43. Shapovalova LA, Shapovalov КA. Pathology of the psychic sphere in patients with epilepsy, revealed by psychiatrist of the regional consultative center of the Subarctic territory. European Psychiatry. 2018; 48: 718-719.
  44. Shapovalova LA, Shapovalov КA. Alcoholic fetal syndrome as obligatory part of lecture on prevention of alcohol use of module "Fundamentals healthy lifestyle" for students of humanitarian and technical universities. European Psychiatry. 2019; 56: 482-483.
  45. Shapovalova LA, Shapovalov КA. "Psychiatry of catastrophes" in the daily work of an outpatient psychiatrist. European Psychiatry. 2019; 56: 546.
  46. Shapovalova LA, Shapovalov КA. Organizational and methodological work in the practice of psychiatric outpatient consultative reception. European Psychiatry. 2019; 56: 552.
  47. Shapovalova LA, Shapovalov КA. Characteristics of mental health of patients of outpatient reception of psychiatrist. European Psychiatry. 2019; 56: 582-583.
  48. Shapovalova LA, Shapovalov KA. Diseases of the mental sphere revealed by the psychiatrist at contingent of patients of the consultative outpatient admission. Arch Psychiatry Mental Health 2019; 3: 012-019.
  49. Shapovalova LA, Shapovalov KA. Psychiatry of disasters. Organization of the work of a psychiatrist outpatient consultative reception. Annals of Psychiatry and Treatment. 2019; 3: 012-022.
  50. Shapovalov КA, Shapovalova LA, Shapovalova PK. On the issue of registration of the section "Scientific and practical work" of the qualification category of a doctor. IX International congress "Orgzdrav-2021. Good governance in healthcare”, Moscow, May 25-27 2021: abstracts. 2021. Pubmed: https://www.vshouz.ru/orgzdrav2021/thesis/27197/
  51. Shapovalova LA, Shapovalov KA, Shapovalova PK. The role and place of scientific research in the work of a psychiatrist. Geneva: World Health Organization. 2021; 1-30.
  52. Shmukler AB. Dokazatel'nye issledovaniya v psihiatrii: analiz prakticheskoj znachimosti. Psihiatriya i psihofarmakoterapiya. 2012; 14: 4-13. Pubmed: https://www.elibrary.ru/item.asp?id=18903518
  53. Ivushkin AA. Sostoyanie nauchnyh issledovanij v psihiatrii na osnovanii naukometricheskogo analiza publikacij otechestvennyh i evropejskogo s"ezdov psihiatrov (2000-2007 gg.). Avtoreferat na soiskanie uchyonoj stepeni kandidata medicinskih nauk. Moskva, 2012. http://mniip-repo.ru/uploads/1341656152.pdf

Similar Articles

Recently Viewed

Read More

Most Viewed

Read More